Insolvency & Bankruptcy Law •5 min read

The ₹6.5 Crore Question: Can a Guarantor Settle ₹22,000 Crore of Claims? Associate Voting, Judicial Supervision and the Subhash Chandra Insolvency

Guriya Singh (B.Sc. LL.B. (Hons.), National Forensic Sciences University)
• •Indian Journal of Insolvency Law
The ₹6.5 Crore Question: Can a Guarantor Settle ₹22,000 Crore of Claims? Associate Voting, Judicial Supervision and the Subhash Chandra Insolvency

Executive Abstract

This article analyzes the complex legal and procedural issues arising from the personal insolvency proceedings of Essel Group founder Subhash Chandra. Examining the controversial NCLT approval of a ₹6.25 crore repayment plan against admitted claims exceeding ₹22,000 crore, the author dissects the critical role of "associate" voting rights under Part III of the IBC. The analysis further explores the jurisdictional conflicts between NCLT benches, the evidentiary burden required to establish associate status, and the broader implications of concurrent criminal investigations by the CBI on the insolvency resolution process, highlighting significant stress points in India's personal insolvency regime.

Introduction

The NCLT approved on 25 August 2026 the repayment plan under which Subhash Chandra, the founder of the Essel Group, would repay creditors ₹6.25 crore, along with ₹25 lakh as process cost in respect of admitted claims of ₹22,006.57 crore, that is about 0.028 per cent of the admitted claims, or a write-off of around 99.97 per cent. The approval of the NCLT was stayed within a week and within days the CBI filed an FIR in connection with another loan.

The issues involved include not only a case of one promoter but also those of extent of interference by the tribunal in a plan approved by the creditors, who is an "associate" and entitled to vote, and co-existence of insolvency and criminal proceedings.

How the case began

The matter in hand is one of insolvency relating to a personal guarantor, which comes under Part III of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code. It was brought forth in 2022 by Indiabulls Housing Finance, which is now called Sammaan Capital, citing provisions of Section 95 in light of a non-repayment of an amount of ₹170 crores, a loan taken by Vivek Infracon, which was personally guaranteed by Chandra. The petition was accepted in April 2024 following the revocation of an interim order of the Supreme Court, and the plan for repayment was voted upon by creditors, which ended on 1st November 2024, in favor with 80.814 per cent voting for it. Officials have also stated that the plan envisages around ₹1,494 crore being paid separately by the principal borrowers.

The vote that decided it

The headline percentage conceals a more acute problem. On account of the voting details given in one report, the five parties considered to be "associates" of Chandra by the dissenting lenders had around 61.78 percent of the voting shares, which means that the resolution would not have been passed without them. Canara Bank, HDFC Bank, IDBI Trusteeship, RBL Bank, and IndusInd Bank challenged these voting rights, and LIC Housing Finance also argued that it will only receive ₹38.09 lakh out of ₹1,322.39 crore claims. As the same account puts it, the associate question turned into the single largest legal battleground.

A split bench and a third member

The original bench of two members was divided. According to the report, Technical Member Reena Sinha Puri rejected the plan outright, Judicial Member Ashok Kumar Bhardwaj wanted its benefit confined to supporting creditors, and Judicial Member Nilesh Sharma, acting as the third member, approved it and made it binding on all creditors. His reasoning states that the Tribunal's function is supervisory rather than investigative; that a forensic audit is not a prerequisite at the plan stage; and that the objecting creditors had failed to establish on the facts that the five entities were "associates". He did, however, exclude claims filed on behalf of 960 and 300 individuals for lack of supporting documents.

Stay, a five-member bench and a procedural fight

On 1 September, a newly formed five-member bench stayed that order and barred Chandra from transferring his properties. Chandra has taken his case to the NCLAT, challenging how the bench was constituted and contending that its order exceeds the jurisdiction granted under the Companies Act. The lenders have filed a separate challenge to the approval. The NCLAT has issued notices and scheduled 29 and 30 October for hearing interim relief, while the five-member bench is due to consider the matter on 19 November. For the time being, the parties are disputing which bench has the authority to decide, before the merits are addressed once more.

The net-worth gap and the CBI

Both tracks revolve around a gap in net worth. Creditors point to 2017-18 certificates that put Chandra's net worth at roughly ₹40,562 crore, and about ₹59,000 crore in another, compared with the ₹31.79 crore he disclosed in 2024. On 5 September, the CBI was reported to have registered an FIR over two loans totalling ₹980 crore from LIC Housing Finance, which records its loss at more than ₹1,322 crore and alleges that inflated net-worth certificates were used. Chandra did not respond immediately. An FIR is an allegation, not a finding of fraud. The tribunal itself has reportedly stated that a mere discrepancy, absent independent proof of concealed or transferred assets, does not by itself block a plan or require a forensic audit, and the NCLT has since asked for the CBI's response within four weeks.

Three questions for the appellate courts

The following is my own evaluation. First, the commercial wisdom of creditors is a well-established principle in corporate insolvency, yet it loses force when parties connected to the debtor are the ones controlling the vote. Second, the associate test: the third member reportedly insisted on proof that the statutory definition had been satisfied, so it may fall to higher forums to determine whether objecting creditors carry that burden, or whether the resolution professional must confirm independence before votes are counted. Thirdly, a compensation scheme that provides for the payment of just a small percentage of the number of admitted claims raises some issues concerning the completeness of the disclosure of assets by the guarantor, which could be challenged through a forensic audit or at the bankruptcy phase that comes later.

Conclusion

The case shows the pressure put on laws regarding personal insolvency, whereby the law which has been set up to help honest guarantors get another chance is being threatened by a scheme which, according to its critics, leaves creditors with practically nothing. It will be determined by the facts, not perceptions of who voted, what information was shared, and what the investigation manages to uncover. Until then, the deal for Rs 6.5 crore hangs in limbo, and, as per reports, no tribunal or court has found any fraud.

Footnotes / References

#Personal Insolvency#Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code#NCLT#Subhash Chandra#Essel Group#Associate Voting#Debt Resolution